| AWAY | HOME | ANDREW | BRIAN | CHRIS | CHUCK | DAVE | ERIC B | ERIC S | EVAN | RAY | RYAN | SCOTT | CONSENSUS | WINNER |
| NYJ | CLE | CLE | NYJ | NYJ | CLE | CLE | NYJ | NYJ | CLE | NYJ | CLE | NYJ | NYJ | CLE |
| BUF | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | no pick | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | MIN | BUF |
| CIN | CAR | CAR | CIN | CAR | no pick | CIN | CAR | CAR | CAR | CAR | CAR | CAR | CAR | CAR |
| DEN | BAL | BAL | BAL | DEN | no pick | DEN | BAL | BAL | BAL | BAL | BAL | BAL | BAL | BAL |
| GB | WAS | GB | GB | WAS | no pick | GB | GB | GB | GB | GB | GB | WAS | GB | WAS |
| IND | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | no pick | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI | PHI |
| NO | ATL | ATL | ATL | ATL | no pick | NO | NO | ATL | ATL | ATL | ATL | ATL | ATL | NO |
| NYG | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | no pick | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | HOU | NYG |
| OAK | MIA | MIA | OAK | OAK | no pick | MIA | OAK | OAK | MIA | MIA | MIA | MIA | MIA | MIA |
| SF | KC | KC | KC | KC | no pick | KC | KC | KC | KC | KC | KC | KC | KC | KC |
| TEN | JAC | JAC | JAC | JAC | no pick | JAC | JAC | JAC | TEN | JAC | JAC | JAC | JAC | TEN |
| LAC | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | no pick | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR | LAR |
| CHI | ARI | CHI | ARI | CHI | no pick | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI | CHI |
| DAL | SEA | SEA | DAL | DAL | no pick | SEA | SEA | SEA | DAL | SEA | SEA | DAL | SEA | SEA |
| NE | DET | NE | NE | NE | no pick | NE | NE | NE | NE | NE | NE | NE | NE | DET |
| PIT | TB | TB | PIT | TB | no pick | TB | TB | PIT | PIT | TB | PIT | TB | TB | PIT |
| Points | 34 | 39 | 49 | no pick | 47 | 56 | 34 | 63 | 43 | 53 | 55 | 47 | 57 | |
* Survivor: bold (as in a "bold" prediction)
** Solo opportunity: red (as in get "red"-dy, here comes an upset)
*** Unani-MISS attempt: blue (as in we really "blue" it this time)
**** Consensus: defaults to home team in case of a tie
